Particular think that once the John informed Herod which wasn’t legitimate having your when planning on taking/provides their brother’s partner, you to definitely created he’d to repent from the divorcing the lady. Take into account the same brand of wording in the event it concerned David taking Bathsheba becoming their spouse. New Bible says that David sinned as the the guy:
“…killed Uriah the fresh new Hittite into blade; you take their wife-to-be your wife…” (dos Sam. 12:9). “…as you features despised Me personally, and also have removed the fresh wife out-of Uriah brand new Hittite become your spouse” (2 Sam. ).
Yet not, to own purpose out-of argument, let’s consider the chance that John try implying it was wrong getting Herod to keep their relationship so you can Herodias
This new sin you to definitely taken place that have David would be the fact he unlawfully got Bathsheba to-be their wife. The guy lied, cheated, and you will killed in order to have Bathsheba. The brand new sin you to definitely occurred having Herod is that the guy unlawfully took Herodias is their spouse. As the repentance failed to request you to definitely David breakup Bathsheba, they really should not be automatically assumed one to repentance demanded that Herod breakup Herodias, particularly when they’d repented of the confessing their sin and inquiring to have forgiveness just like the David did (dos Sam. ). If the eg had been the truth, upcoming God might have “set aside” the sin exactly as The guy performed with David and you will Bathsheba (2 Sam. ). For example repentance and you will forgiveness don’t need a future divorce proceedings.
Also, in the event the one got his brother’s partner in marriage, it was an effective sin although Bible assumes the happy couple do naturally keep within relationship. Envision Leviticus :
Whilst it is an effective sin to marry their brother’s partner, it really claims that they create suffer caused by are childless in their marriage. There is nothing said in the breakup.
In the event the instance is the case, we have to inquire, “as to why?” It didn’t become given that they a new wedding try molded immediately following a separation. How can we know it?
Whenever i features showcased during the this research, we should instead keep every thing in the perspective. John rebuked Herod not as much as Jewish laws, centered Jewish legislation (Heb. 9:9-15). UnderJewish legislation, only the child could divorce or separation the lady. When the kid did breakup their, she got a certificate off divorce and you may is actually free to wed other child.
A lady is bound to her spouse beneath the laws since the enough time because they was partnered in which he stayed
But not, in the event the a woman wasn’t divorced from the the woman husband significantly less than Jewish rules, up coming she could not marry other son up to the girl husband divorced the girl and you may gave their new certificate away from divorce or separation (Deut twenty four:1-4; Rom. 7:1-4; 1 Cor. 7:39). A lady cannot getting married to a different child under Jewish law until the girl partner died otherwise divorced the lady and you will she got their divorce proceedings certification.
The thing that makes that it crucial? This is very important since Philip never separated Herodias. By the Jewish law (legislation of your residential property she is actually under), she did not have the lady separation certificate become liberated to marry another son. Indeed, we will find that Herodias performed the same thing you to definitely the girl great-cousin did.
Josephus wrote from the Salome, brand new cousin of Herod the good, Herodias’ great-sis. Josephus refers to their step up against the girl partner Costobarus:
“She delivered him a bill out of divorce or separation and you will demolished her relationships with your, though it was perhaps not with regards to the Jewish laws, having with our company it’s legal getting a partner to complete so; but a spouse; if she actually leaves away from the girl partner, usually do not of herself end up being married to a different, unless of course their previous husband put the lady out. Yet not, Salome made a decision to realize maybe not what the law states regarding her nation, but the rules of the lady power, and thus renounced the girl wedlock” (Antiquities fifteen.eight.10)